Please enable JavaScript to view this site.

RootsMagic lets you apply a quality rating to each use of your citations based on the industry-standard Elizabeth Shown Mills, "Process Map for Evidence Analysis", Evidence Explained: Citing History Sources from Artifacts to Cyberspace (Baltimore, Maryland: Genealogy Publishing, 2007).

 

From her discussion, Sources give us information from which we select evidence for analysis. A sound conclusion may be considered Proof.

 

To enter your quality ratings

 

After careful analysis and evaluation of the associated source, you can enter a quality rating in each of three factors that best describes the results of your analysis.

 

You will see the 3 Quality options when you are editing a citation on the edit person form. Just click each item and select the appropriate value from the drop list that appears.

 

RM9_EditPerson-Citation

 

Source

Original - This source is in its first recorded form

Derivative - This source is extracted, transcribed or otherwise derived from the original

Don't know

 

Information

Primary - This information was provided by someone with firsthand knowledge of the person or fact

Secondary - This information was provided by someone with secondhand knowledge of the person or fact

Don't know

 

Evidence

Direct - This source answers the research question by itself

Indirect - This source is relevant, but needs additional information

Negative - This source is missing information that it should contain

Don't know

 

The quality is at the citation use level, since the same source (or even the same citation) can have a different quality depending on what it is used for. For example, a birth certificate could have a different quality depending on whether it was used for the person's birth, or used for the father's place of birth.

  

Keyboard Navigation

F7 for caret browsing
Hold ALT and press letter

This Info: ALT+q
Page Header: ALT+h
Topic Header: ALT+t
Topic Body: ALT+b
Contents: ALT+c
Search: ALT+s
Exit Menu/Up: ESC